Borrower insurance represents a significant share of the total cost of a mortgage, sometimes as much as the interest itself. Since the Lemoine Law, borrowers have been able to switch policies at any time, with no fees or penalties. The market has opened up, and the number of offers has grown.
Even so, the CCSF report published in January 2024 showed that the share of external alternative policies had risen only from 15.3% at the end of 2021 to 16.1% in May 2023: growth remains modest. Choosing insurance suited to a property purchase therefore means looking beyond the instinct to accept the group policy offered by the bank.
Indemnity method: the factor that makes all the difference in borrower insurance
Before price, before coverage, the indemnity method determines what the policy actually pays out in the event of a claim. Two approaches coexist, with radically different financial consequences.
A fixed-benefit policy pays the scheduled monthly instalment, regardless of any income the borrower continues to receive (daily benefits, a spouse’s income). The amount is set when the policy is taken out and does not depend on the borrower’s circumstances at the time of the claim.
An indemnity-based policy, by contrast, calculates the payout according to the actual loss of income. If the borrower receives benefits from Social Security or supplementary insurance, the reimbursement is reduced accordingly. For an executive with good employer-provided coverage, the difference can mean several hundred euros in out-of-pocket costs each month.
Another point worth looking into is insurance on Mon Conseiller Immo, which can help explain the coverage mechanisms associated with a loan. The indemnity method is set out in the policy’s terms and conditions, but is rarely highlighted by online comparison sites.

Definition of incapacity for work: own occupation or any occupation
Borrower insurance policies cover temporary incapacity for work and permanent disability. The actual scope of this coverage depends on a clause often buried in the policy’s specific terms: the definition used to assess incapacity.
A policy based on the definition of “any occupation” only pays out if the insured person is unable to perform any kind of work. A surgeon who can no longer operate but could theoretically take an administrative job may receive nothing.
The “own occupation” definition protects borrowers in the job they actually do—the one they held when the claim arose. For manual workers, people in high-risk occupations and self-employed professionals, this distinction fundamentally changes the protection they receive.
Bank group policies often use the “any occupation” definition. Policies taken out through insurance delegation are more likely to offer the “own occupation” definition, sometimes as a paid option. Checking this before signing can prevent an unpleasant surprise at the worst possible time.
Exclusions and medically unobservable conditions: the blind spots in an insurance policy
Policy exclusions are the least transparent part of borrower insurance. Among them, the treatment of medically unobservable conditions (MNOs) deserves particular attention.
MNOs include conditions whose diagnosis is based mainly on the patient’s own reports: lower back pain, depression, burnout and fibromyalgia. By default, most policies exclude MNOs from incapacity coverage. A borrower who takes time off work due to depression will not receive benefits unless they have taken out a specific exclusion buyback option.
Buying back the MNO exclusion adds to the cost, but covers conditions that are among the leading causes of sick leave in France. A young, healthy borrower may be tempted to skip it. That decision can prove costly if a prolonged period off work occurs midway through loan repayments.
Beyond MNOs, exclusions relating to high-risk sports, business travel abroad or pre-existing conditions vary from one policy to another. The standardised information sheet (FSI) that the bank must provide allows borrowers to compare exclusions, but it is not enough on its own: the full terms and conditions remain the definitive reference.
Borrower insurance coverage for couples buying a home
When two co-borrowers take out a mortgage, the allocation of insurance coverage determines each person’s level of protection. The bank requires a minimum total coverage of 100%, but the split between the two borrowers is negotiable.
- A 50/50 split divides the risk equally. If one co-borrower dies, the insurance covers only half of the monthly payments. The surviving borrower must cover the other half alone.
- A 100/100 split fully covers the outstanding loan balance, regardless of which borrower makes a claim. Insurance costs more, but the coverage is comprehensive.
- An uneven split (70/30, 80/20) can reflect differences in income between co-borrowers. The higher earner takes a larger share, protecting the household if its main source of income is lost.
The coverage split applies for the entire term of the loan. Changing it after signing means switching policies. For a couple with unequal incomes, 100% coverage for the main earner and 50% for the other borrower is often a reasonable balance between cost and protection.
Medical questionnaire exemption and the AERAS Convention: two schemes to know about
The Lemoine Law introduced an exemption from the medical questionnaire subject to certain conditions: the insured amount per person must not exceed 200,000 euros, and the loan must be repaid before the insured person’s 60th birthday. For a couple, the amount to consider is each person’s share of the coverage, not the total amount borrowed.
A sole borrower taking out a 250,000-euro loan with 100% coverage cannot qualify for this exemption. Two co-borrowers taking out the same loan with a 50/50 split (125,000 euros each) are eligible, provided they meet the age requirement.
For borrowers with a history of health problems, the AERAS Convention provides for a three-level review. A medical history does not automatically mean an insurance application will be refused. The right to be forgotten, strengthened by the Lemoine Law, shortens the period after which certain conditions—particularly cancers—no longer need to be declared.

The cost of borrower insurance should be assessed using the TAEA (annual effective insurance rate), not the nominal rate. This rate, which must be stated in policy offers, makes it possible to compare policies on a like-for-like basis. A difference of just a few tenths of a percentage point in the TAEA can add up to several thousand euros over the term of the loan.
A comparison is only meaningful when coverage is equivalent: the same indemnity method, the same definition of incapacity and the same treatment of MNOs. Without this framework, the lowest price may conceal the weakest coverage.




